SecurityBrief Australia logo
Australia's leading source of cybersecurity and cyber-attack news
Story image

Govt's data breach bill will unleash confusion, says expert

By Shannon Williams
Mon 7 Mar 2016
FYI, this story is more than a year old

Australian organisations will struggle to comply with the Federal Government’s mandatory data breach notification proposals, according to consulting firm Protivity.

The company says unless detailed guidance is developed and consultation processes with the Privacy Commissioner are introduced to businesses determine whether they have a notification obligation, there will be compliance confusion.

In its submission to the Federal Government’s consultation on the draft Bill requiring organisations to notify affected individuals and the Privacy Commissioner where they have been hit by a serious data security breach, Protiviti observed that unlike the European Union and United States, where an entity’s notification obligations are clearly defined, Australia’s draft legislation introduces sketchier concepts that could require organisations to make subjective judgement calls.

Specifically, Protivity says the draft Bill requires entities to decide whether there are ‘reasonable grounds’ to believe a ‘serious data breach’ has occurred resulting in a ‘real risk of serious harm’ to affected individuals, before their notification obligation is triggered. 

According to Ewen Ferguson, managing director at Protiviti, it will often be difficult for entities to judge whether all these thresholds are met. 

“After all, there’s a wide spectrum of circumstances in which a data breach can occur, ranging from an employee losing a laptop containing a limited amount of non-financial personal information, to a large scale malicious theft of credit card details,” says Ferguson.

“There will always be a multitude of factors at play and the outcome will not always be straightforward,” he says.

“What’s more, in many cases it will not be clear who has acquired the data, and how or for what purposes the data was compromised, making it difficult for companies to gauge the severity and impact of the breach,” Ferguson explains.

Ferguson says that because the draft laws establish a ‘self-assessment’ regime, whenever the facts are ‘borderline’ or where a case for non-disclosure is at least arguable, it is more than likely that organisations will decide not to notify to avoid the reputational impact of public scrutiny. 

“The danger of a regime that encourages entities to ‘err on the side of non-disclosure’ is that it may not adequately protect the individuals affected by data breaches, as potentially ‘serious’ breaches may go unreported,” he explains.

Ferguson says this concern be addressed in two ways.

“Firstly, to help organisations to accurately ‘self-assess’ their notification obligations, it’s essential that the Commissioner issue detailed criteria and case-study style guidance on how these concepts might operate in practice,” he says.

“Secondly, there must be an avenue for entities to approach the Commissioner’s office for prompt, in-confidence advice on whether their notification obligations apply in cases where the outcome is unclear.

“This may be established as an administrative process by the Commissioner’s Office or formally in legislation similar to the way federal tax laws allow taxpayers to apply to the Australian Taxation Office for a binding ‘ruling’ on how the tax law applies to their circumstances,” says Ferguson.

“In any event, the process must be an expedited one where the Commissioner commits to making a prompt determination,” he continues.

“Time is critical where data breaches are concerned and the process should not unduly prejudice an individual’s ability to take swift action to protect their interests where their data has been compromised,” Ferguson adds.

In its submission, Protiviti also expressed concerns that the proposed breach notification scheme may not encourage significant numbers of organisations to improve their data security in view of the light penalties for non-compliance.

“Despite the increasing incidence of cyber-attacks and existing fines of up to $1.7 million for breaches of the Privacy Act, many entities still do not have adequate controls to prevent or detect data breaches”, Ferguson explains.

“The cost for medium and large companies to upgrade information security practices to the standard required to identify a breach or reduce the likelihood of one occurring, could outweigh the maximum penalty of $1.7 million proposed by the breach notification laws,” he says.

“This may predispose some companies to run the risk of incurring a data breach because the quantifiable penalties are relatively insignificant. 

“Many companies continue to step up their data security for ethical and reputational reasons anyway, irrespective of the penalty, because it is the ‘right thing to do’.

“However, for the few who don’t, a stiff penalty may well be the only effective wake-up call,” Ferguson says.

"If one of the key objectives of the proposed data notification laws is to encourage entities to take greater preventative measures to secure personal data, then the penalties for non-compliance under both the current Privacy Act and the proposed breach notification Bill, must be raised to a level that makes the cost of taking preventative action worthwhile, for the minority of companies that won’t choose to do the right thing,” he explains.

Examples of indicative benchmarks from other jurisdictions include the European Union’s new General Data Protection Regulation which imposes a fine of up to 4% of global annual turnover, while Californian law permits affected parties to take civil action including class actions.

Related stories
Top stories
Story image
SaaS
Ping Identity appoints Deloitte Australia as a partner
Ping Identity has appointed Deloitte Australia as a Consulting Technology Partner, uniting its offerings with the company's consulting services.
Story image
Training
Barracuda customises training to fit ACSC Essential Eight
Barracuda has announced that its Security Awareness Training now provides a customised training curriculum in line with the Australian Cyber Security Centre’s (ACSC) Essential Eight.
Story image
Ransomware
Examining the future of ransomware threats with Vectra’s CTO
As customers' valuable data move to the cloud, so will ransomware. What is the current landscape and what do we need to know?
Story image
Apple
Your tools, your choice: why allow employees to choose their own devices?
Jamf Australia says giving your team the freedom to work with their digital device of choice could help to attract and retain top talent in a tight labour market.
Story image
Digital Fingerprint
Decline in counterfeit cherries after digital fingerprinting
Reid Fruits says there’s been a dramatic decline in counterfeit products for its cherries over the past three export seasons to Asia because of digital fingerprinting.
Story image
Research
New study reveals 51% of employees using unauthorised apps
The research shows that 92% of employees and managers in large enterprises want full control over applications, but they don't have it.
Story image
Gartner
Gartner's top recommendations for security leaders
"Leaders now recognise that major disruption is only one crisis away. We can’t control it, but we can evolve our thinking, philosophy, program and architecture.”
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Eight top DevSecOps trends to support IT innovation in 2022
The use of DevSecOps practices is growing, as it is increasingly seen as the best way to produce high-quality and secure code. So what are the current trends?
Story image
Apple
Jamf introduces new content filtering solution for education providers
Jamf has announced the launch of Jamf Safe Internet, a new offering that looks to deliver a safe online experience to students while offering better management options for admins.
Story image
Cloudera
Overcoming hybrid and multi-cloud challenges to drive innovation
Driven by improvements in technology, financial services companies have advanced both internal and external systems and processes, with the likes of digitisation, personalisation and risk management redefining the industry.
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Vectra AI named as AWS security competency partner
Threat detection and response company Vectra AI has announced that it has become an Amazon Web Services Security Competency Partner.
Story image
Cloud Security
Palo Alto Networks bolsters cloud native security offerings
Latest Prisma Cloud platform updates help organisations continuously monitor and secure web applications with maximum flexibility.
Story image
Documentation
Adobe study finds lack of digital trust and utilisation in Australian Government agencies
New research commissioned by Adobe has revealed a significant lack of digital trust within Australian Government departments, along with the continued underutilisation of key digital processes.
Story image
Cybersecurity
How organisations can mitigate IoT and IIoT security risks
IoT and IIoT come with inherent risks because they are often deployed faster than they can be secured, putting organisations in danger of cyber threats. Here are tips on how to mitigate those risks.
Story image
MSP
Video: 10 Minute IT Jams - An update from CyberArk
Olly Stimpson joins us today to discuss the importance of MSP programmes and how MSP partners are experiencing success with CyberArk.
Story image
Cyber Criminal
Identity and access: the fight is on
Blue team defenders are used to protecting our data, applications, and users with access controls and other security mechanisms, which is why attacks like this are especially challenging when they target identity and access control systems.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Security driving customer identity & access management adoption
"CIAM allows businesses to embed a secure identity layer into their consumer and SaaS applications, facilitating secure, seamless end user experiences."
Story image
Solutions
Progress launches latest version of network visibility solution
In Flowmon 12 network solution, Progress has expanded its support for public cloud provider flow log monitoring and launched new features.
Story image
Remote Working
RDP attacks on the rise, Kaspersky experts offer advice
"Given that remote work is here to stay, we urge companies to seriously look into securing their remote and hybrid workforce to protect their data."
Story image
Oracle Cloud
Commvault, Oracle to deliver Metallic Data Management as a Service
"We are excited to partner with Commvault and enable our customers to restore and recover their most mission-critical cloud data."
Story image
Tech job moves
Tech job moves - ActiveCampaign, Arcserve, LogRhythm & Qlik
We round up all job appointments from June 17-22, 2022, in one place to keep you updated with the latest from across the tech industries.
Story image
State Library of Victoria
State Library of Victoria entrusts Oracle support and security to Rimini Street
“Our finance team are very happy with the support and security that Rimini Street provides, which keeps our assets and our customers secure."
Story image
Compliance
SentinelOne integrates with Torq to empower security teams
"With Torq, security teams can extend the power of SentinelOne to systems across the organisation to benefit from a proactive security posture.”
Story image
Cybersecurity
Without trust, your security team is dead in the water
The rise of cyberattacks has increased the need for sound security that works across any type of business, but with any change, buy-in is essential. Airwallex explains why.
Story image
API
Industry-first comprehensive risk-based API security enhances protection
Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) have become a crucial part of operating web and mobile application businesses and are causing significant economic growth in the digital sector.
Story image
Internet of Things
ManageEngine wins big in IDC MarketScape assessment
ManageEngine's Endpoint Central service has been recognised as a leader by IDC MarketScape in several categories including Internet of Things device deployments and UEM software for SMEs.
Story image
Internet of Things
Domino's Pizza: A blueprint for secure enterprise IoT deployment
Increasingly, organisations are embracing smart technologies to underpin innovations that can enhance safety and productivity in every part of our lives, from industrial systems, utilities, and building management to various forms of business enablement.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Email threats spike 101%, remains a top attack vector
"Each year we see innovation in the threat landscape, but each year email remains a major threat to organisations."
Story image
Enterprise Resource Planning / ERP
Five ways your ERP is letting you down and why it's time for a change
Wiise explains while moving to a new system may seem daunting, the truth is that legacy systems could be holding your business back.
PwC
WSLHD and PwC’s Consulting Business came together to solve through the challenges of COVID-19. A model of care was developed to the NSW Health Agency for Clinical Innovation guidelines with new technology platforms and an entirely new workforce.
Link image
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Juniper study reveals top AI trends in APAC region
Juniper's research shows an increase in enterprise artificial intelligence adoption over the last 12 months is yielding tangible benefits to organisations.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Zero trust security adoption rises 27% in just two years
A survey of WAN managers has revealed that multi-factor authentication and single sign-on are the top zero trust features implemented.
Story image
Cybersecurity
FIDO Alliance releases guidelines for optimising UX with FIDO Security Keys
The new guidelines aim to accelerate multi-factor authentication deployment and adoption with FIDO security keys.
Story image
Tech job moves
Tech job moves - Bitdefender, Cohesity, Fortinet & MODIFI
We round up all job appointments from June 27-30, 2022, in one place to keep you updated with the latest from across the tech industries.
Story image
Trend Micro
5G network projects driven by improving security and privacy
Trend Micro's new study reveals the prospect of improved security and privacy capabilities are the main motivations behind private 5G wireless network projects.
Story image
Ransomware
Businesses unprepared to defend against ransomware attacks
Ransomware attacks continue to impact organisations worldwide with high costs, but businesses are still largely unprepared.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Tech and data’s role in the changing face of compliance
Accenture's study found that 93% of respondents agree or strongly agree new technologies such as AI and cloud make compliance easier.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Palo Alto Networks' cloud security platform receives IRAP assessment
"We provide help protect all forms of compute, cloud native services and access to data within public and private sectors."
Story image
Payroll
How New South Wales state departments achieved cloud migration success
State departments in New South Wales are heading to the cloud to achieve better workflow solutions, and one company is paving the way for their success.
Story image
WatchGuard Technologies
Ransomware volume doubled 2021 total by end of Q1 2022
Ransomware detections in the first quarter of this year doubled the total volume reported for 2021, according to a new report. 
PwC
PwC's Consulting Business and PwC's Indigenous Consulting are proud to play an important role in helping Australian Indigenous Mentoring Experience build IMAGI-NATION, a free online university for marginalised communities around the world.
Link image
Story image
Malware
Colt launches new SASE Gateway solution with Versa
Colt Technology Services’ customers now have access to an integrated full SASE solution that brings together SD WAN and SSE features.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Vulnerable APIs costing businesses billions every year
Large companies are particularly vulnerable to the security risks associated with exposed or unprotected APIs as they accelerate digital transformation.  
Story image
Compliance
Stock security features inadequate in face of rising risk
"Organisations must proactively find ways of identifying unseen vulnerabilities and should take a diligent, holistic approach to cybersecurity."